WHY nesma & sara ?

[SoNyA]

i heard they had to sing twice @ eval..why ONLY them two ??

[hhh]

because apparently they only acted in their evaluation , so they asked them to sing

[SoNyA]

oh ok then thanx asoum

[Nicole]

Nesma did sing in the first chance "i don't know if you can call it singing" and after the eval she went upstairs and said that she "Sang" well...... apparently it wasn't good enough for the teachers so they gave her second chance for the song.

[Ana Magnonet Sawt Sara]

WOW AND THEY DID THAT FOR SARAH LUCKY PEOPLE!!!!

[D]

They didn't show most of Sarah's eval because it had to do with religion. So I don't know what the extent of the singing was.
And Nesma's "singing" wasn't really, because in the scene she was crying while teaching her daughter a song, so she acted it out like that rather than sing the song.

I think it was totally unfair to have Sarah and Nesma sing again. They only gave them the chance because they knew they couldn't nominate them at this point, and they would have had to based on the fact the that they didn't sing. If it was, let's say, M. Rahma and Liyan who "didn't get the requirements" and didn't sing or sing enough in the eval, would they have given them a second chance? Of course not. It would have been a nomination.

[iSamoora- Maghraby ❤]

No D, they gave them a second chance because they didn't understand the evaluation. Everyone else sang and acted, they were the only 2 who didn't so I think it's not that unfair.

[D]

I think that was the teachers' excuse so they wouldn't have to nominate them. I'm not blaming the girls. I'm blaming the unfairness in the show.
There is nooooooo way they would have called down Karim or Mohamad Abdallah if they made that mistake and told them you have a second chance to sing. They would have just nominated them and told them they are nominated because they didn't sing.

[iSamoora- Maghraby ❤]

No but it's only the 3rd eval with the first time needing a scene with singing so they told them you guys don't understand the instructions so they gave them a second chance, if they did it again they wouldn't give them a third chance.

I see your point, but I can't say anything until it actually happens, they seem pretty fair this year so i don't know, maybe you're right maybe not maybe if karim really didn't sing they would've told him come back and sing and maybe not you never know.

[Matilda]

Nesma is the primes light.No need for evals anyway.

Sara an x-rated porn star.

[SoNyA]

Apr 18, 2011 19:47:09 GMT -5 Matilda said:

Nesma is the primes light.No need for evals anyway.

Sara an x-rated porn star.

..& you were acting in her movies?!!!!!

[Matilda]

Apr 19, 2011 15:40:39 GMT -5 SoNyA said:

Apr 18, 2011 19:47:09 GMT -5 Matilda said:

Nesma is the primes light.No need for evals anyway.

Sara an x-rated porn star.

..& you were acting in her movies?!!!!!

OMG! no way...I'm a great jewish, how can somebody like me one of the god's chosen people do whatever this **** is doing. I don't even do this in private with any of my friends.