REEM SALMA'S SISTER IN STARAC 3

[Fan]

Hey i just knew that Reem Salma's sister is in starac3 i hope its true

[Fan]

Reem is Salma Ghazali Sister the one who came as a surprise last year with her brother she will be in starac 3

[hind]

Fan said:

Reem is Salma Ghazali Sister the one who came as a surprise last year with her brother she will be in starac 3

oh yeah i remember now thanks i hope that her voice is batter then her sister's with all my respect to her fans

[Nononono]

hind said:

Fan said:

Reem is Salma Ghazali Sister the one who came as a surprise last year with her brother she will be in starac 3

oh yeah i remember now thanks i hope that her voice is batter then her sister's with all my respect to her fans

Don't hope! Because Reem doesn't speaks arabic very well & she's not a singer loool

[sumy!!]

guyssss if wht all they have been saying abt the people in starac3 is correct .. then
we will have somone from bashar's familly
reem salma's sister
nancy's brother
and i guess there was someone else but i can't rememebr
OMG relatives academy !!!

[Miss You sisters]

scratch said:

Don't hope! Because Reem doesn't speaks arabic very well & she's not a singer loool

Of course she speaks Arabic---Algerian Arabic that is. I agree that she's not a singer. If they did accept her there would be no doubt in mind that they did it to have someone to eliminate early... Like they did with Anas.

[guest]

intika said:

scratch said:

Don't hope! Because Reem doesn't speaks arabic very well & she's not a singer loool

Of course she speaks Arabic---Algerian Arabic that is. I agree that she's not a singer. If they did accept her there would be no doubt in mind that they did it to have someone to eliminate early... Like they did with Anas.

Reem comes from a francophone middle class family, so I agree that Arabic and especially not Oriental would be her cup of tea..she will face the same problems with Arabic that Sofia Selma and Hanane had..they would be better off singing French..plus Selma at least spoke Lebanese but Reem knows only Algerian..But I don't agree that you have to be a singer to be in Star Academy..you are there to become a singer as long as you have a promising voice..

intika

[guest]

One more thing, Star academy is not solely based on voice: dance, playing instruments, musical background, looks, physique, persona, charisma, mentality, nationality are all taken into consideration. I think what matters essentially when you apply there is simply the fact if they like you or not and if you click with the teachers..I don't think they chose necessarily the ones with the best voices. What if you have a golden voice but you suck in all the other criterias, I don't think they will pick you. So it's also based on luck.

intika

guest said:

One more thing, Star academy is not solely based on voice: dance, playing instruments, musical background, looks, physique, persona, charisma, mentality, nationality are all taken into consideration. I think what matters essentially when you apply there is simply the fact if they like you or not and if you click with the teachers..I don't think they chose necessarily the ones with the best voices. What if you have a golden voice but you suck in all the other criterias, I don't think they will pick you. So it's also based on luck.

intika

nationality??

besides, i agree with you tht its better to have all talents you mentioned..but id like to mention tht th concept on which "endemol" based this program/show..is mainly th vocal talent, if u see all countries where th phenomenon starac exists,you know tht all winners through all editions,so far are basically good singers

[Nononono]

But she's so cute!!!

intika said:

scratch said:

Don't hope! Because Reem doesn't speaks arabic very well & she's not a singer loool

Of course she speaks Arabic---Algerian Arabic that is. I agree that she's not a singer. If they did accept her there would be no doubt in mind that they did it to have someone to eliminate early... Like they did with Anas.

omg intika, you mentioned anas...in th wrong way; mind poster girl hahaha

i agree with wht u said,though

[guest]

king said:

guest said:

One more thing, Star academy is not solely based on voice: dance, playing instruments, musical background, looks, physique, persona, charisma, mentality, nationality are all taken into consideration. I think what matters essentially when you apply there is simply the fact if they like you or not and if you click with the teachers..I don't think they chose necessarily the ones with the best voices. What if you have a golden voice but you suck in all the other criterias, I don't think they will pick you. So it's also based on luck.

intika

nationality??

besides, i agree with you tht its better to have all talents you mentioned..but id like to mention tht th concept on which "endemol" based this program/show..is mainly th vocal talent, if u see all countries where th phenomenon starac exists,you know tht all winners through all editions,so far are basically good singers

Yes let's be honest the nationality of a candidate can play in or against his favor..or else why would they choose to make castings in certains countries without others..and in both editions some nationalities seem to be more present than others..

I am not sure about the other star academies, but in both editions of this star academy it was indicated that voice is not all what takes to win if you are a bit lacking in this criteria but you could balance it out with another quality you could win

guest said:

king said:

nationality??

besides, i agree with you tht its better to have all talents you mentioned..but id like to mention tht th concept on which "endemol" based this program/show..is mainly th vocal talent, if u see all countries where th phenomenon starac exists,you know tht all winners through all editions,so far are basically good singers

Yes let's be honest the nationality of a candidate can play in or against his favor..or else why would they choose to make castings in certains countries without others..and in both editions some nationalities seem to be more present than others..

I am not sure about the other star academies, but in both editions of this star academy it was indicated that voice is not all what takes to win if you are a bit lacking in this criteria but you could balance it out with another quality you could win

well i think they choose to make castings in countries
1- where they know tht they will get talents easily
2-where countries allow them to
3- where lbc interests are garanteed

abt th lbc starac editions.. many extra elements played an important role in finals. i refer you to wht was said then im not interested in tht anymore ;D

[guest]

king said:

guest said:

Yes let's be honest the nationality of a candidate can play in or against his favor..or else why would they choose to make castings in certains countries without others..and in both editions some nationalities seem to be more present than others..

I am not sure about the other star academies, but in both editions of this star academy it was indicated that voice is not all what takes to win if you are a bit lacking in this criteria but you could balance it out with another quality you could win

well i think they choose to make castings in countries
1- where they know tht they will get talents easily
2-where countries allow them to
3- where lbc interests are garanteed

abt th lbc starac editions.. many extra elements played an important role in finals. i refer you to wht was said then im not interested in tht anymore ;D

So you do agree with me that nationality plays a factor ;D I don't agree with your first reason c'est un prejugé, and I don't know what you mean by the second one

Yes I know..and I don't wanna go into the details neither ;D

guest said:

king said:

well i think they choose to make castings in countries
1- where they know tht they will get talents easily
2-where countries allow them to
3- where lbc interests are garanteed

abt th lbc starac editions.. many extra elements played an important role in finals. i refer you to wht was said then im not interested in tht anymore ;D

So you do agree with me that nationality plays a factor ;D I don't agree with your first reason c'est un prejugé, and I don't know what you mean by the second one

Yes I know..and I don't wanna go into the details neither ;D

i call it "countries" u call it"nationalities"..
my 1st reason isnt "préjugé" it is reality..whn they go to Egypt,Lebanon;Tunisia,Kuwait,Syria..etc,they know they WILL get talents easily,its a fact. i don't mean tht in other countries there no talents..get me?
2nd reason is self explanatory tho,not all countries allow lbc to come & choose young ppl to be selected 4 singing competitions
are you fr maghreb? ;D